Review:
Acting wise, the performance by Fred MacMurray is timeless. Just fantastic! Now i'll be teh first to admit that the profuse sweating was a little unnecessary. But if you watch this movie and don't see the nervous, emotional, immoral Walter that Fred MacMurray portrays as anything but amazing, you're dead inside. And how did Barbara Stanwyck not win an Academy Award for her performance? This is one of the more original roles I've seen an actress portray in a film, none the less for a film made in the 1940's!
* Side note, Stanwyck's character ranks up in the top 3 Femme Fatales, behind Sharon Stone in Basic Instinct and Glenn Close in Fatal Attraction.
When I overheard people talking about this movie, some said that they had no remorse for the character of Walter which in my opinion is preposterous. There has to be a certain level of forgiveness and sympathy for Walter, otherwise I think his actions throughout the movie are seen as just petty criminal acts and the betrayal by Phyllis at the end will hold no impact. Also, from the reading I found that there was a deleted scene that is "lost in annals of history" showing Walter getting killed in the gas chamber. The studio said it was "too gruesome!!" excuse my French but f*ck that. That would have made this film AMAZING!
I cannot in give this film a high enough recommendation. 10 stars out of 10. Simply one of the better crime drama films I've seen in a long time and one of the better Film Noir movies I've ever seen. Fantastic...
I thought the way he said "baby" was obnoxious. The speed in which he said it was just strung along with all the other words which hid the emotion behind it.
ReplyDeleteThe manner of speaking in this film made me chuckle throughout. It was one of those movies where the conversations were cool, but unrealistic. Like in the movie Juno, where they talked cool and everyone liked that but no one actually talks that way in real life.
ReplyDeleteAnd yes, I was one of the people is unlikely to feel remorse for Walter. I think it's because of the role of the Femme Fatale as used in these films. The filmmaker seems to try to make you feel sorry for the man because he was tricked into doing something bad by the evil woman. I think that's just a cop out and these dudes need to man up and stop thinking in their pants. Then maybe they wouldn't get into as much trouble.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteSo many great points in this post! For one, I didn't even think about The Usual Suspects. In my post I made a point of saying that there were similarities between Double Indemnity and Memento but The Usual Suspects is such a good comparison.
ReplyDeleteGreat point about the speaking in the film. I mentioned Walter Neff's voice in my post and I also was a big fan. Yeah it was a little corny at times but memorable nonetheless.
Another interesting thing you mentioned was the use of the door. I'm glad you pointed this out because I feel like I'll now be conscious of these types of things. This moment was really intense. The use of the door and the blocking of the characters was crucial.
I personally didn't like the idea of the gas chamber ending. I don't know. The very last shot where Keyes lights the match and the camera fades seems so poignant. I feel like a scene where Walter is killed in a gas chamber at the very end wouldn't fit very well.